Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe is a family-owned bakery and café in Tyrone, PA, where fresh food, thoughtful service, and homemade flavor come together every day.
Every item is made from scratch and baked fresh daily, giving customers a delicious reason to stop in for a quick visit, pick up a treat, or enjoy a satisfying meal.
From cookies, cakes, cupcakes, pies, apple dumplings, coffee cake, cinnamon rolls, sticky buns, and cannoli to a wide selection of other baked goods, the shop offers something for every sweet tooth and every occasion. Coffee is also available, making it easy to pair a freshly prepared drink with a favorite pastry or dessert.
The menu extends well beyond baked goods, with pizza, stromboli, subs, macaroni and cheese, and daily specials prepared for customers seeking a hearty lunch or convenient meal. Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe also welcomes catering and custom orders, providing a dependable option for celebrations, gatherings, business events, and special dessert requests.
Whether you need a beautifully prepared cake, a selection of pastries for a group, or a freshly made meal on the go, the team is ready to help make ordering simple and enjoyable.
Customers can choose from on-site service, takeaway, and delivery, with credit cards and debit cards accepted for added convenience. The location includes a wheelchair-accessible car park, helping make visits easier for more guests.
With a perfect 5.00 out of 5 rating based on 58 customer reviews, Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe has earned strong praise for its fresh preparation, welcoming family-owned atmosphere, and broad selection.
Visit the bakery and café at 3209 S 4th St, Tyrone, PA 16686, call +1 814-330-5213, or find Sugar Mill Bakery & Cafe on Facebook for updates and custom-order information.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Hear from our valued guests
Sugar mill is going to become a Tyrone staple ( along with macs, &east end pizza.) Their food is fresh and incredible. I recommend the house pizza and buffalo chicken dip Stromboli. I have not tried a sub yet but imagine they are just as tasty.
Always excellent food! I love the buffalo chicken dip stromboli/pizza - it is soo good. Also, tried the Dominator today - all the flavors meshed so well together. Absolutely delicious! Everyone is always so pleasant to deal with. Sugar Mill Bakery is a new staple in this household!
We had lots of technical difficulties communicating through Facebook. I recommend just calling. We're glad to have this business in Tyrone. They looked up a recipe for us and made our special request and it was delicious. We love that they have delivery. Prices are worth it because we know the ingredients are fresh and supporting local business!
Fantastic place for a quick food pickup, just a quick detour from the highway. The sub sandwiches - on fresh baked bread- are outstanding. Try the turkey bacon ranch sub.
First off they are super nice there and always willing to help make your order experience as easy as possible. Got the chicken parm pizza last night, it was really good! I got off at 5 and they closed at 5 but was willing to wait a little longer so I was able to get my order which is going the extra mile for their customers! I grabbed an oatmeal raisin cookie and some puppy chow fudge while I was there! The oatmeal raisin cookie was by far the best I’ve had. Just so nice to have such a great addition to our little town.
Do not walk, RUN to try this place. Hands down the best food and baked goods in the Tyrone area. So glad this place opened up, I would drive an hour to get this food, luckily I can just have it delivered instead. Everything fresh made daily including their rolls/pizza dough. The sticky buns are life changing! It is take out only and they do delivery Friday and Sunday. Follow them on Facebook for their specials.
We ordered cupcakes for a birthday party and picked up pizza when we stopped in. Everything was FABULOUS, with large portions and unique, delicious flavor combinations. The service was great as well, as they helped me carry everything to my car and were kind and friendly to my preschooler. Looking forward to making The Sugar Mill a regular stop!!
Small locally owned business and their pizza is phenomenal. Perfect sauce, crispy bottom and the dough is tasty. The peanut buttet cookies are to die for we will be back. And ooen on Sundays yessssss. Check them out for sure.
We went to try their baked goods to rate them, however they were sold out of mostly everything, but good for them!!! We got a chocolate and vanilla cupcake, I ate the chocolate cupcake before I remembered to take pictures, lol. Great, delicious, chocolate tasting cake on the chocolate cupcake, vanilla was... idk weird certainly not fresh and not moist like the chocolate cake was...icing was very very sweet. Chocolate chip cookie was idk weird again, not bad, just weird. Almost like it's a sugar cookie base with chocolate chips added, idk just not what I was expecting with a chocolate chip cookie. I wouldn't get anything again except the chocolate cake minus the icing. Counter person was great, very clean place!
I order here often and am always impressed. Tried the supreme cheesesteak special and it was amazing! Very generous portions and all fresh ingredients. The bakery items are always delicious; especially the Italian love cake! I have never had a bad experience here - the staff are always very kind and accommodating.
Common questions about Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe
Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe is located at 3209 S 4th St, Tyrone, PA 16686, United States, Tyrone, PA, United States.
You can reach Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe by calling +1 814-330-5213.
Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe has a rating of 5.0 out of 5 based on 58 customer reviews.
Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park.
Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe features the following from the business: Small Business.
Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe features the following service options: On-site services, Takeaway, Delivery.
Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe features the following offerings: Coffee.
Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe features the following planning: Quick visit.
Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards.
Sugar Mill Bakery and Cafe features the following parking: Free parking lot, Free street parking.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
